Saturday, 13 April 2024

Cognitive Miser

 

Cognitive Miser


    The Gosp River ran thick and slow through Mossystone Town [1]. It was in the post-pandemic (covid) era, spring 2023. Megan Tennant, the town's culture councilor, created a new activity at the town's annual spring games. The background of this game was to allow the new young inhabitants to get to know the streets of the town and its establishments better, with the objective of increasing knowledge and empathy between the new inhabitants, the streets of the town, and its small businesses. This was because in the last five years the population of the town has increased considerably due to the installation of a large international company in the industrial zone of the town called Trailblazers Valley, which is about two miles east of the town centre, so Megan, with the support of Mayor Max Scott and Melanie Bardell, the administrator's county, created a game called "Where's the Postman?"

The game was for two teams of three participants each, where all of them were from Mossystone High School. The selection of participants process was carried out through a test of knowledge of the streets, squares, shops, and monuments of Mossystone. The winner team was prized by an exposition of images and quotes from the game's performance in the museum during the summer at the town hall. The rules were pretty simple, Knowing that the local postman, whose name was John, starts working at Mossystone's streets at 7 a.m. from the post office, which is an old building in the center of the city, close to the town hall, the task of the participants would be to find the postman through the streets of the town, so they would start the search at 11 a.m., they were allowed to ask establishment attendants or residents of the town about the postman to get clues about where he was. Obviously, the team that managed to find the postman first would be the winner.

It was 10:30 when Jordan Hansen arrived at the city hall building; he was the last to arrive. There were Erin Parham and Kyra Tyler from his team; Iris Covington, Theo Lason, and Doug White from the other team; and culture councillor Megan Tennant, who was the creator and person responsible for running out the game. At that moment, the weather changed unexpectedly. The sky darkened very quickly with blackish clouds, and a cold breeze began to blow. In Megan's head, when she was organising this event, it seemed like a popular event on a bright day where many locals would be interested in this game, but the reality was that there was no one else there other than the two teams and herself, and on top of that, the weather did not invite anyone at all for this event. Notwithstanding, Megan was ready to start the game. She gave the instructions to the participants and commented that the postman had already been warned that high school students would be looking for him, but that, however, he had to continue doing his job as a usual day.

Mossystone Town is split to the both sides of the Gosp River, with the north of the city on one side and the south on the other. The city has grown from the north side, which has three main streets parallel to the river: High Street, Medium Street, and Low Street (next to the river). All the new buildings have been built in this area. There are three bridges to cross the river: the Green Bridge in the west, the Stone Bridge in the middle (it is the old town), and the newest, the New Stone Bridge, which is in the east, near the industrial area. The old town sits mainly on the south side of the city; the main street is Heathrow Road. From there, you can go to the town hall, the post office, banks, shops, restaurants, etc. And then, crossing the Stone Bridge, you reach the poorest part of the old town, with a small harbour for fishing boats.

It was 11:03 when Megan allowed the participants to begin the postman search, she was hoping to meet them again in approximately a couple or three hours at the same location. As an instinct act, each team started in opposite sides of Heathrow Road, soon losing sight of each other. Jordan's team saw a bakery shop, so Jordan and Kyra went straight to ask if they had seen the postman around. The attendant said that he had no idea about the postman this morning, Kyra figured out that the postman had started in the opposite direction of the Heathrow Road, towards the eastern part of town, so they switched their direction. Erin was following them behind. Ten minutes later, when they left the post office behind, they went into a convenience store. Again, the attendant said she had no idea about the postman. At that moment, it was raining, and their clothes began to get wet. Jordan guessed that the postman was not there because he must have started his work on the other side of the river. Then they crossed the Stone Bridge. At this time, Erin was still following a little behind, but she began to frown. On the Low Street next to the river, they saw the lights of a small pharmacy, so Jordan decided to ask there, and again, the attendant said the postman hadn't shown up yet. Then again, Kyra suspected that the postman must be in the opposite direction of the Low Street, Jordan agreed, but Erin said, 'STOP IT!' Kyra and Jordan looked at Erin, surprised. 'What?' Jordan said.


'Stop acting like cognitive misers; we can't be running around like decapitated chickens.' Erin said.
'So what do you propose we should do then?' Kira said.
'something more than just asking if the postman has stopped by or not, because what are we going to do now if in the next store the attendant says again that she has no idea about the postman? go to the north? And then what if the same thing happens again? We should simply stop for a second and think about it; I could assume that the postman delivers by areas, and furthermore, there may be areas that may not be in the same order every day of the week. We should also take into account whether the postman uses a car, bicycle, trolley, or simply walks to change areas.’

Then Erin turned around, saying 'follow me', and Jordan and Kyra did so without complaint. Erin went to the pharmacy again and apologetically asked for more information about the postman, considering it was a Wednesday at 11:40. The attendant and a friendly customer were in the store. They explained to them that on Wednesdays the postman use to come around 1:00 p.m.; in fact, it was one of the last areas the postman did before returning to the post office, and they added that at this time the postman used to be at the east of Medium Street and that it is easy to find him because he uses a red troller that used to be tied to a street light or a fence on the sidewalk that used to be on a street corner where it is easy to see from different sides, so the attendant said, 'if you find the red troller, stay there because the postman will appear soon.' So, after that information, it was easy for the team to find the troller and then the postman, which let them win the competition.

When they were returning to the town hall, the rain had already stopped, and the black clouds began to disperse while a warm ray of sunlight began to aim over their heads. Jordan and Kyra were very grateful to Erin; they have definitely learned something from Erin in this game.






Toni Font Bardolet, Aberdeen 13/04/2024

Friday, 15 September 2023

Misconceptions Around Competitiveness


Misconceptions Around Competitiveness

    Mentioning it exclusively in individual terms, competitiveness can be referred to as an individual behaviour either towards a specific goal or as a general form of behaviour towards the outside world. There are no ethical problems with being competitive as long as a person strives to do the best by achieving something, being aware that the people around them can perform better, or assuming that perhaps they are not yet ready for the goal they want. Notwithstanding, being competitive can be a problem if one loses the perspective mentioned above. Part of that comes from messages sent by agents who lurk around the wildest capitalism. An example of this could be the books and talks that became popular at the beginning of this century about self-help to be a successful person. In those books and talks, there were messages like “If you want 10, go for 20”, or "Defeat is not an option; the only thing that matters is winning; who wants to be a loser?" that are toxic and can lead people to lose their way and begin to see other people as mere adversaries who must be defeated instead of human beings with feelings that can be hurt. They can also lead people to reduce the meaning of life to mere competition, losing the perspective that life is more than that. On the other hand, although the ontological meaning of being competitive implies competing with someone who has the same objective of ultimately winning or being surpassed by another, is that really what it is about? Yes, indeed, but let's put aside the term “competitiveness” for a moment and focus on the individual skills that one must have to be competitive that have been achieved through an individual process. Let's make a few assumptions with a quick construction using a simplistic premise in which I use the term "filter" as the process in which humans decode information from the outside world in a genuine way, just to set up the background. Each one of us has a cognitive filter through which everything we perceive from the outside world is filtered and decoded in a genuine way, so our experiences throughout life—fears, intrinsic survival skills, enjoyment, etc.—have partly shaped this filter, as I assume that the other percentage of this shaping is innate; we already have it when we get born. That would help explain how two people who are born in the same conditions, environments, and social contexts can be completely different from each other. Therefore, this shaped filter has a direct influence on our actions and, consequently, on the development of our skills, so each person perceives things differently (maybe slightly, maybe intensely); therefore, our skills are genuinely different from each other.



Featured by AI

Returning to the beginning of this article, in which I proposed competitiveness as a behavior that could be taken in the wrong way, my approach is that although circumstances lead people to compete with others for the same objective, in the end it is not about overcoming or being surpassed by someone but rather having better specific skills at a specific time for a specific objective, which, as a person, does not imply being better or worse, nor being a winner or a loser or other toxic messages that have been spread through for agents with dubious objectives. Therefore, there is no one to defeat, and there is no reason to be afraid of being defeated and feeling like a loser since each person has genuine abilities. It's about what skills best fit a specific goal at a specific time.


 
Antoni Font 15/09/2023 (revised 22/09/2023), Aberdeen.

Tuesday, 29 August 2023

Is it really their opposite will?

 Is it really their opposite will?


Peter, Sharon, and Jack were Catalan independence supporters who enjoyed the Basque movement during the 80s and 90s, which is why, whenever they could, they attended the popular festivals in Donostia, Gasteiz, Irunea, Bilbao, etc., normally called "Semana Grande". They were more of the radical left side in politics, and they used to go through the streets of the old town where there were popular pubs where people with similar ways of thinking enjoyed the parties, drinking, singing, laughing, arguing, taking drugs, well, there was a bit of everything. So one year in the mid-90s, they were on their last day of vacation in Donostia. On this day, there was an annual event called "Salve" that was commanded by Spanish unionists. This event ran through the streets of Donostia. It was a provocative event; there used to be incidents between the protesters against that event and the police forces that protected it. So, after Peter, Emile, and Jack had lunch, they started an argument. Peter wanted to go to protest against the unionist event, while Sharon and Jack didn't want to risk missing the train back home because the police arrested them. At this time, Peter got angry and went to the train station. It didn't make sense for him to be in the old town and leave before the demonstration started just because they didn't want to take risks. On the other hand, Sharon and Jack saw nothing wrong with staying there for a while instead of spending the last hours of their vacation cooped up in the station bar. In the end, Peter met two girls from Barcelona at the station bar. They enjoyed the afternoon together, drinking and sharing experiences. Sharon and Jack did not appear at the station, so Peter went to Barcelona without knowing anything about his friends. At that time, there were still no mobile phones, so there was little Peter could do. Even so, before the departure of the train, Peter had the dilemma: what should he do? Walking the streets looking for them? What if they catch the next train while he looks for them? In the end, they were adults, and Peter had no way of doing anything that would really produce satisfying results. Peter was right; the next day the three of them met in their small town, and Sharon and Jack explained how, unintentionally, they were abducted towards the manifestation where they suddenly found themselves on the front line of the conflict where the police were shooting rubber bullets at them. Sharot was able to catch a ball that she kept as a battle trophy. Many, many years later, Peter is still thinking about how willingness and reality can be in an opposite way many times; at the end, the circumstances command us, despite our willingness. So, those who wanted not to take a risk were at risk, and those who wanted the risk got free.


Featured by AI

Well, could it be a double psychological effect? Maybe Sharon and Jack didn't dare admit that they wanted to see the conflict, and this served as an excuse for Peter to avoid it.

Who knows?

 
Antoni Font 29/08/2023, Aberdeen.