Saturday, 27 December 2025

0.05 (Trilogy: Part Two)

 

0.05

(Trilogy: Part Two)


    After class, Colum approached Helen as she was packing her notes. “Thanks again for last week’s explanation about null-hypothesis” he said, “but, there is something else that I’m still struggling with, it is about why 0.05 is treated as such an important threshold. Why this reference point?” Helen smiled. “That’s a very natural question. Once the null hypothesis makes sense, people usually start questioning the reference point we use. And you’re right — 0.05 is a reference point more than anything else.” “That’s exactly how it feels,” Colum replied. “Why that number, specifically?” “Let me explain it with an example,” she said. “My father is a builder, and he once explained something very similar to me.” Colum nodded saying “Okeeey…so…”, encouraging her to continue. “When my dad worked on houses built on undeveloped land — places with no clear boundaries or existing markers — the first thing they did was bring in a surveyor — a professional who measures and maps land. Before any construction could begin, the surveyor placed an iron rod firmly into the ground.” “Just to mark a position?” Colum asked. “Exactly. The rod wasn’t special in itself,” Helen explained. “But once it was there, everything else could be measured from it. All the lines of the land, all the angles, all the foundations were defined in relation to that single fixed point.” “So everyone was working from the same reference,” Colum said. “Yes. To avoid errors accumulating, the surveyor always returned to that same rod. In that way, they created a reference point from nothing, simply so construction could begin.” “And once the house was finished?” Colum asked. “The rod became completely useless,” Helen replied. “But without it, the house could never have been built.” Colum paused, then smiled slightly. “I think I see where this is going.” “That’s what 0.05 is in statistics,” she said. “We deal with probabilities, not certainties. Statistics don’t prove things — they tell us how likely a result is to occur by chance.” “So 0.05 is more of a shared agreement than a rule of nature,” Colum said. “Exactly. The scientific community needed a common reference point to decide when a result is unlikely to be due to chance alone. In psychology, we usually use 0.05, although other fields choose stricter thresholds, such as 0.01.” “And what does 0.05 actually mean?” he asked. “It means that if the null hypothesis were true,” Helen explained, “there would be only a 5% chance of observing results like the ones you obtained purely by chance. Put another way, it suggests a 95% probability that the observed effect is not simply random variation.”

“So it doesn’t mean the result is definitely real,” Colum said.
“No,” she replied. “It doesn’t make a result true or false. It simply tells us that, according to the reference point we’ve agreed to use, the data are unlikely to be random.” “Like your father’s iron rod,” Colum said. “Exactly,” Helen replied. “It’s not perfect, and it’s not a law of nature. But it gives everyone the same baseline, so we can build knowledge without endless disagreement.” Colum nodded, visibly relieved. “That actually makes a lot of sense now. Thank you.” “You’re welcome,” Helen said. “Once the house is standing, the rod no longer matters — but without it, nothing ever gets built.”

Toni Font, 28/12/2025. Aberdeen.

Wednesday, 17 December 2025

Untranslatable

 

Untranslatable


    Translation between languages is often feasible at a general or surface level. However, when semantic precision is required, direct translation may fail to preserve the intended meaning. In such cases, literal or culturally biased interpretations can result in significant distortions of the original message. A clear example can be found in the comparison between Catalan and English. In English, constructions such as “I have to do” or “I have had to do” typically encode a sense of obligation or necessity. In Catalan, the structurally equivalent expressions “haig de fer” and “he hagut de fer” may appear to convey the same meaning. Yet, depending on the context, these forms do not necessarily imply obligation. Rather, they can function as explanatory or justificatory devices, providing reasons for an action or accounting for its consequences, without conveying any sense of external or internal compulsion. When such an expression—e.g., “he hagut de fer”—is translated literally into English, the pragmatic force of the original utterance may be misrepresented. A native English speaker is likely to interpret “you have had to” as implying constraint or obligation, leading to a misunderstanding of the speaker’s intent—it happened to me recently. This illustrates how grammatical equivalence does not guarantee pragmatic equivalence.


This issue extends beyond isolated examples. Approximately one year ago, I translated one of my Catalan texts into English. After revisiting the translation, I concluded that the central message of the original text was not adequately conveyed and ultimately removed it. The conceptual core of the text resisted translation, highlighting the difficulty of transferring meaning across languages when it is deeply embedded in linguistic and cultural structures. For this reason, composing texts directly in the target language may, in some cases, be more effective than translating from a source language. Across the spectrum of each language, there are corners where semantic and pragmatic domains are not fully translatable, particularly when dealing with abstract, affective, or culturally grounded meanings. Rather than representing a deficiency, this limitation reflects the richness and diversity of linguistic systems. Preserving this diversity is essential, as it embodies distinct ways of conceptualising and interpreting human experience.

Toni Font, 17/12/2025. Aberdeen.

Thursday, 11 December 2025

The Null Hypothesis… Why? (Trilogy: Part One)

  

The Null Hypothesis… Why?

(Trilogy: Part One)

   “Null hypotheses may be boring, but they're very useful.”


After class, Colum walked straight up to his psychology teacher, Helen, with a puzzled look on his face.
“Sorry, Helen… I still don’t understand,” he said. “Why do psychologists test the null hypothesis instead of the actual hypothesis they care about?” Helen smiled gently, as if she had heard this question many times before. “That’s a very good question,” she replied. “The funny thing is that we do care about the real hypothesis — the alternative — but we test it indirectly.” “Indirectly?” Colum asked, frowning. “How?” “Well,” Helen said, “the null hypothesis gives us a very precise and clear prediction because it describes what usually happens. For example, if it rains and we’re outside, we expect to get wet. That’s the normal situation — nothing unusual, nothing unexpected.” Colum crossed his arms. “Okay… but why can’t we just measure the hypothesis itself?” Helen chuckled softly. “Because the alternative hypothesis — the one we actually care about — is usually far too vague. Let me give you a simple example.” She picked up a pen from her desk, as if acting out a small scene. “Imagine the claim I just mentioned: if it rains, people get wet. That’s a clean, testable prediction. We can easily measure two things: whether it rained, and how wet people got. Simple.” “Right,” Colum said, nodding. “That’s straightforward.” “Now imagine the opposite claim,” Helen continued, “which would be our hypothesis: if it rains, people won’t get wet. Okay… but why wouldn’t they get wet? Maybe they used an umbrella, or wore a waterproof coat, or stood under a roof, or ran very fast," she couldn't hide an ironic smile about her own words, "...or the rain was light, or the wind blew the drops away. You see? There are endless possibilities.”


Colum raised an eyebrow. “So… what would we even measure then?” “That's the point,” Helen replied. “So, the alternative doesn’t give us one clear thing to test. But the null hypothesis does.” She paused briefly, then went on. “So then, here’s what we do: we test the precise prediction made by the null hypothesis. If the data don’t fit that prediction — if it rains and people somehow don’t get wet — then the null hypothesis becomes unlikely. And when the null fails, our hypothesis succeeds.” Colum’s expression finally brightened. “Ah… so when the null hypothesis fails, the real hypothesis becomes the more believable explanation!” “Exactly,” Helen said. “We support the alternative hypothesis indirectly, by showing that the null hypothesis’s prediction doesn’t match reality.” Colum sighed with relief and smiled. “Okay, now I get why psychologists focus so much on the null hypothesis. Thanks, Helen.” “Any time,” Helen said with a wink. “Null hypotheses may be boring, but they’re very useful.”


Toni Font, Aberdeen 11/12/2025