So, Then, What Are We Looking For?
On an ordinary Wednesday evening at Barni's Pub in Mossystone, the usual crowd had gathered. Among them were again Jack and Steven, this time they were debating about football.
What had started as a discussion about team performance was becoming increasingly philosophical.
"Look at that squad," Jack said, taking a sip of his beer. "On paper, they've got everything. Top players, top manager, plenty of money. Yet they're so far having a terrible season."
Steven nodded agreely.
"... and then you've got teams with half the budget and none of the big names somehow outperforming them."
"Exactly," said Jack. "so we can say that sometimes what looks like a guaranteed success ends up being a disaster, and what seems average turns into a winner."
Steven leaned back in his chair and said: "That reminds me of something I've always wondered."
Jack raised an eyebrow.
"What's that?"
Steven paused for a moment before asking:
"So then, in general terms... what are we really looking for when we build a team; the best players or I don't know....something else?"
Jack shrugged.
"I suppouse the best people, surely. The most talented, the most skilled, the most experienced."
"That's what most people would say," Steven replied. "It sounds logical. But history keeps teaching us a different lesson."
"What do you mean?" said Jack.
"Think about it. Time and time again, people have assembled the best resources, the best experts, the latest technology, and the most talented individuals available. Everything looked perfect on paper."
"And then?"
"And then it failed."
Jack laughed.
"Fair point. But why?"
"Because something was missing."
"What?"
"The human factor."
Jack frowned.
"The human factor?"
"Trust. Motivation. Commitment. Purpose. The ability to work together. Those things can't simply be bought. They grow when people feel valued and when they're part of something fair and meaningful."
"So you're saying having the best individuals doesn't automatically produce the best results?"
"Somehow yes, I do."
Steven pointed towards the television where highlights from a football match were playing.
"That's why experienced managers sometimes make decisions that fans don't understand."
"You mean when they leave a star player on the bench?"
"Precisely. Everyone complains because, on paper, it looks like the wrong choice. But sometimes the manager knows something the statistics don't show. He knows how people influence each other, how personalities fit together, and what makes a team function."
Jack nodded slowly.
"I've seen that happen."
Steven thoughtful said: "Want another example?"
"Go on."
"Music."
Jack chuckled.
"I wasn't expecting that."
"Think about it. Some people are incredible singers. Others are brilliant guitarists or pianists. Technically, they're masters of their craft."
"Sure."
"But how often do those world-class musicians perform songs written by someone who isn't a great singer or instrumentalist?"
Jack thought for a moment.
"Quite often, actually."
"Exactly. The composer might not have the strongest voice or the fastest fingers. Yet they possess something else."
"Like what?"
"Vision. Creativity. The ability to connect ideas and inspire others."
After a little thoughtful pause Steven add:
"They create something that gives all those talented performers a reason to come together."
"So the real value isn't always technical skill."
"Technical skill matters," Steven replied. "Of course it does. But it isn't everything at all."
Jack looked around the pub for a moment before speaking.
"So what you're saying is that the greatest achievements happen when talented people are united by something bigger than themselves."
Steven smiled.
"Now you're getting it."
For a few moments, they both watched the football highlights in silence.
Finally, Jack turned back to his friend.
"So then, what are we really looking for?"
Steven set down his glass.
"Not just the best people on paper."
"What then?"
"We're looking for the environment, the leadership, and the human connections that allow people to give their best."
"Exactly," said Steven.
"It's about how well they can do it together."
Toni Font, Aberdeen 03/06/2026

