Cognitive Overload
Jack: "Why did it take you so long to confess?"
Shon: "I don't know; I guess I was scared."
An ordinary Friday for Peter, Jack, Shon, Jacob, and Paul took an exciting turn this winter evening as snow blanketed their little town of Greenstone. This added a special thrill for these young post-teenagers. After playing their punk music at the small venue provided by the council for the town's youth, they headed to Barni's pub to enjoy some sandwiches and drinks.
As the night went on, a magical aura enveloped the boys, drawing them out of the pub and into the town center. They had a 5-liter plastic container of calimotxo (a mix of red wine and Coca-Cola) that the bar attendant had agreed to make for them at a reasonable price. They were all in high spirits, singing punk songs and laughing at their current jokes.
The snow on the streets was dirty and almost melted, but in a locked park with a football pitch, the snow remained a pristine white. Paul encouraged his friends to jump the locked fence and play on the snowy pitch. They quickly set up a game: Jacob was the goalkeeper, Peter and Shon were one team, and Jack and Paul were the other. Using the now-empty container as the ball, they played as they had many times before, with the first team to score three goals winning.
Shon, having less football skill and patience, was always quick to tackle his opponents. He started a friendly tussle with Jack, and the slippery snow made it even more fun. As they wrestled on the snowy pitch, a blue light suddenly illuminated the white snow—it was a police car on the other side of the fence. Seeing the light, Peter, Jacob, and Paul bolted to escape on the opposite side of the park. However, it was too late for Shon and Jack; the police recognized them by name. There was no point in escaping since everyone knew each other in their small town.
During the ride to the police station, Jack stared fixedly at the car roof with a "why me?" expression, determined to get out of the station as soon as possible. Meanwhile, Shon couldn't focus his gaze anywhere, constantly shifting and switching his thoughts. The police officer on duty at the station, Helen Robinson, decided to apply protocol D-2 for these two young men. This meant they would be interrogated separately by different agents at the same time, and afterward, the officers would compare the information they had gathered.
Officer Neil takes a statement from Jack:
Neil: Hi Jack, what were you doing in the locked park at that time of night?
Jack: We were just having fun playing football in the snow with a plastic container as a ball. Why did you take us here? You know who we are, where we live, and who our parents are. I can even tell you the names of those who escaped. I’m not worried because we did nothing wrong, and you know it.
Neil: Yes, we know who you are, but if the council locks a public place for a reason, it must be respected. You didn’t respect that.
Jack: Fine, give me a fine if you want, but there’s no reason to treat us like criminals. There’s nothing valuable to steal or break, and we weren’t bothering anyone. We were alone. Just let me go. I have nothing else to say.
Neil: Ok, thank you, Jack.
Officer Chris takes a statement from Shon:
Chris: Hi Shon, what were you doing in the locked park at that time of night?
Shon: I was with Jack having a chat.
Chris: But we saw other people running away. Who were they?
Shon: I don’t know; I didn’t pay attention to them.
Chris: So, where were the rest of your group, Paul, Jacob, and the others you’re always with?
Shon: Maybe at Barni’s pub. Yeah, I guess so.
Chris: Why were you two having a chat in a locked park?
Shon: Um... well, maybe for privacy.
...(and the questioning continued for quite a while)...
Shon was overwhelmed by many thoughts, caught between his loyalty to friends and his desire to be a good citizen—values that seemed irrelevant in his current situation. This cognitive overload prevented him from realizing, as Jack did, that they hadn’t done anything seriously wrong. There was no real need to withhold his friends' names or worry about being a good citizen in this context.
When Jack finished his declaration, he had to wait a long time for Shon to complete his, even though they had started simultaneously. When Shon finally emerged from the adjoining room, Jack asked, "Why did it take you so long to confess?"
"I don't know; I guess I was scared," Shon responded.
"Oh mate! You're absolutely mental," Jack commented resigned.
Toni Font Bardolet, Aberdeen 19/07/2024